Showing posts with label History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label History. Show all posts

Friday, November 18, 2022

The BRADLEY

 


A sad song, yes, but one of my personal favorites to play around this time of year. And Lee Murdock has become one of my favorite singers.

Tuesday, March 23, 2021

Palace Gossip

 “I ran into Tobias, the kitchen boy, earlier this evening. He looked nervous.”

“Tobias is always nervous, Nathaniel. His first day, he shook so hard he nearly dropped the roast pheasant.”


“Well, then he’s more nervous than usual. It’s his turn to take food up to the king.”


“Oh, I see.”


“Joash, I don’t know what’s come over the king, but…”


“He disobeyed God during the Amalekite campaign, you know that.”


“Well, yes, but still, this is getting out of hand. Tobias said that last night, one of the other kitchen boys—I think his name’s Caleb—let slip some remark about David and got a facefull of lamb stew.” 


“Is he alright?”


“I think so, though Tobias said the guy won’t come out of his quarters. There may be two holed up in there by tomorrow.”


“I don’t blame him. Normally I’d say he’s just shirking, but with the king going mad lately, I’m inclined to be generous.”


“Rebekah said two more servants quit yesterday.”


“That makes, what, five this week?” 


“Six, if you count that one missing guard.”


“He’s dead, remember? He got drunk and fell from a window.” 


“Oh, right.”


“Joash, Nathaniel, are you in?”


“Yes, Reuben. What is it?”


“Do you have the totals for this storeroom?”


“They’re right here.”


“Thank you, Joash. Hey, uh, did either of you see Leah, the washerwoman?”


“No, why?”


“I heard the king tried to strangle her.”


“Who told you that?”


“Abigail, one of the serving maids.”


“I wouldn’t trust her if I were you. I know the king’s off his head, but Abigail’s known to twist words around.”


“So, she lied about Tobias getting a black eye?”


Tuesday, March 10, 2020

Gagarin Mourns For Komarov

Why did this happen?
The Soyuz was not ready.
It had many flaws.

I begged them to stop,
To allow for more testing.
They would not hear me.

You flew to your death 
In a rocket ill-designed,
Because of their haste.


Friday, March 6, 2020

Bondarenko

           I wanted to fly
           But I did not get the chance.
           I died in a blaze.

           Some people believe
           If my death was made public,
           Three men might still live.
           

Tuesday, March 3, 2020

Haiku Time

No more leaving this thing sitting for months on end. 


Dr. Boli spent last month doing Haiku. I figure I might give it shot. I will keep this about music, but will add other things to keep my creativity alive. I started my Space Race binge again, so here are two about the Nedelin Catastrophe:

 
                       Khruschev says to launch
                       The rocket filled with venom.
                       Ninety plus are dead.
                    
                       No rockets will fly
                       On that day forevermore
                       To respect the dead.

 I will write another one tomorrow.











Friday, December 13, 2019

TMSR: YOU KNOW NOTHING, VAL DICTORIAN!

I am going to rant now about a musical that I was in when I was eleven-years-old. Most people will not have heard about this one because it is written for kids who are either in home-school groups or big church groups.

This musical was written by Kathie Hill and is titled Promise U. Ms. Hill's work tends to be okay at best (at least from my own experience), and at worst it is simply glurge. And Promise U falls hard into that second category. What a piece of drek! There are five reasons why I say this:

1) The plot does not exist.
    The setting is at a college called Promise University and the whole student body has gathered for a pep rally/study hall Cram n Jam. They are learning about "Precious Promises to Famous Followers of the Past 2,000 Years" or P2F2P2K. Leading the group is the cocky DJ Stan "The Man" and a sexy nerd of a cheer captain Valarie Dictorian. They go through seven so-called Famous Followers, do a cheer after every song and it all culminates in Stan becoming a Christian with everything all hunk-dory at the end. 
    That's it, there's no conflict or anything. All it is is just talking about various people from history and a promise that applies to them. There's no beginning, no middle, and no real end either.

2) The characters are shallow.
     They are little more than cartoony mouthpieces uttering platitudes in stained glass attitudes. A new character comes in every time another "Famous Follower" (oh, give me a break!) is introduced. These characters are not really given a personality so much as they are given a quirk, and these quirks get old really fast. For example, Dee Caffeinate's only trait is her coffee obsession, and Val Dictorian comes off as a condescending know-nothing-know-it-all. 

3) The evangelism is all too easy. 
    Stan admits he's in over his head at the end, but it comes out of nowhere and doesn't feel real. All he has seen and heard was what everyone else was chanting. His character is so flat that I do not believe his life has been changed after accepted Christ. No one talks about dying to yourself and giving up whatever idols are in your life, something that is essential to the Christian life.

4) THE Promise is left out.
    The "Precious Promises" are true, but no mention is made at all of the promise that was made in Genesis Chapter 3 and continues through the end of Revelation; the promise of Christ's sacrifice and resurrection and the hope of eternal life with Him in Heaven. The promises are reduced to cutesy sentimentalism that do not require sacrifice of anything. This is a big "No" when writing Christian pieces. 

5) The Followers were treated without respect.
     If you're going to do a case-study of various Christians throughout history, then the topic needs to be treated seriously. This is not the case in Promise U, instead the Followers are treated with more sentimentality than respect. This is particularly bad with the case of Pocahontas. I'm not going to knock her faith just because it sounded it like the writer was merely speculating. But if she was in fact a strong woman of faith, then she needs more respect than just the Christian version of a Disney Princess!

 In short, Promise U was garbage. It is disrespectful towards Christians of the past, is insulting to kids' intelligence, and it had nothing to offer but preachy nonsense. 

Sunday, November 25, 2018

ALBION'S SEED: Four English Folkways In America

This thick, massive tome by Professor David Hackett Fischer is about the four main English groups who settled America in the 17th and 18th Centuries.  The book explores their impact on America's socio-political landscape and how it still affects our society even today.  These four groups are the Puritans, Cavaliers, Quakers, and Scots-Irish.  Each group settled in a different region and brought their own customs and folkways with them.  
      Fischer defines "folkways" not as something primitive dating from way back when, but as a complex system of beliefs and customs that remain the same even as a culture goes through change.  These are often found in the way people talk, their architecture, family structure, marriage rituals, death rituals, food, etc..  And we can still see the impact of these customs today.  

The Puritans were the first wave of English to come to the New World.  These are the famous "Pilgrims" who landed at Plymouth Rock and celebrated the first Thanksgiving with their Indigenous neighbors.  Staunch Calvinists, they believed that Christ only died for the elect and looked for signs of God's favor.  They are infamous for their obsessive fear of witchcraft.  It was the Puritans founded the Ivy League schools in Massachusetts and Connecticut, and are the ancestors of today's Liberal elite.

The Cavaliers were the second group to cross over the Atlantic.  In fact, a certain governor of Virginia intended to bring over second sons of the nobility in order to recreate the old Feudal system.  These became the planter class that dominated Southern society.  Cavaliers tended to be Anglican and held loyalty to the king.  Among them were the ancestors of Robert E. Lee and George Washington. 

The Quakers were the third set to come to America, settling in places like Delaware.  Called the Society of Friends, they focused on what they called the "Inner Light" and the work of the Holy Spirit.  They were very strict in areas such as sex and marriage to the point of asceticism.  This led to one group breaking away and becoming the now-extinct Shaker sect.  The Quakers would later become leading players in the Abolition Movement of the 19th Century.  

The Scots-Irish were the last group to arrive in the U.S., settling in the border areas and the Appalachian Mountains.  They have long held a reputation for being fierce and vicious fighters, in fact, many were brought over to be the barrier between the Europeans and the Indigenous tribes.  The Scots-Irish were a very clannish group and feuds were a way of life.  The most famous of these was the feud between the Hatfields and McCoys, which started as a quarrel over livestock and resulted in the deaths of nearly twenty people.  Surprisingly, a majority of American Presidents were Scot-Irish, including Andrew Jackson, Ulysses S. Grant, and Ronald Reagan. 
           
Albion's Seed is a demanding read, but a good read nonetheless.  It does a good job of explaining who settled where and when, what customs they brought with them, and how it has shaped our society and continues to do so. 

Monday, October 1, 2018

Reenactments in the Rain

It was making down like a drizzle on and off yesterday at the Wade House.  The 10:30 cavalry skirmish was canceled, but they were able to recreate part of the Battle of South Mountain.  I haven't studied South Mountain that much, but it was one of the events leading up to Antietam in 1862.  
        One of the highlights of yesterday's fight was the one brown horse was actually being obedient this year.  In the past that horse would panic at sound of a gunshot.  This year, he was listening to his master a lot more, for which I am glad.  When I saw the horse's nervousness the first year, it was mildly understandable.  But it got annoying in the following years. 

The Medical Demonstrations are always as must.  One reenactress is actually descended from the very first woman doctor Rebecca Chisholm.  She even has some of her ancestress' original medical tools!  The stories of Civil War hospitals being complete hellholes were exaggerated to varying degrees, but then again a lot of these guys are in searing agony and doctors still didn't know much of what we do now.  But the piles of dead arms and legs were blown out of proportion after the Battle of Gettysburg (the weather had been very hot that time and there was a shortage of water for the field hospitals).  
          The reenactors show how surgeons did their jobs back in the 1860s.  Among other things they showed was an early version of the stethoscope.  Apparently it was invented because doctors had to press their ear against the patient's chest to listen to the heartbeat, and you can imagine how awkward it must have been for male doctors when they had to do it with a woman patient.  So someone made a little trumpet-like tool press against the patient's chest so as to make hearing the heartbeat easier with minimal physical contact.  
      The doctor's performed a simulated operation on a dummy whereby they try to remove a bullet from a patient's wounded leg.  If the bullet does not appear to have broken the bone, they can save the limb.  If the bone is broken, they may have to amputate the limb to save the person's life.  Sometimes they might try "sectioning", carefully removing an inch of the broken bone, which would render the limb slightly shorter than before.  The doctor's desk had an array of medical books and little bottles of medicines. 
[During the surgery simulator one little boy kept hiding his face in his mother's shirt.  No surprise there, the concept of cutting someone open is very disturbing to the majority of people.] 

Because of the drizzle it was muddy out.  It was also chilly and we had to get my boyfriend a pair of mittens because his hands got cold quickly.  It also meant that we were pressing close together to keep warm.  He and I tend to do that anyway, but the cold weather made it all the more necessary because sweaters and cardigans aren't quite enough when the temperature is less than 50 degrees Fahrenheit.  
          One of the stalls was selling smoking hats.  I was a little surprised because they looked exactly like the hats worn by people in Qing Dynasty China.  At the time, partly thanks to the two Opium Wars, people in China took to smoking in certain rooms.  This also took off in the U.S. and Europe, and Chinese-style smoking jackets and smoking hats were popular.  Men wore them over their regular clothes so that the tobacco did not stick to them.  I have been in a house where people were smoking all the time, and the smell of tobacco never leaves the place.

We got turned around several time going to the Kettle Moraine Visitor's Center and we got there twenty minutes before closing time.  But were able to enjoy ten minutes of the little museum and getting my boyfriend a mammoth T-Shirt.  It was too wet and chilly to go out on the observation deck, though. 



 

Saturday, September 30, 2017

Grant Couldn't Sing

As an opera lover and history buff, I sometimes wonder what it might be like to write an opera about the American Civil War.  Now this would be very tricky, and if any of you have read my previous post on the issue, you know that I have some very strong opinions about operas based of historical characters.  Still the concept is interesting, and if treated properly you could get something amazing.  


Now one of my most favorite figures in American History (and in all of history for that matter), is Union General Ulysses S. Grant.  I've recently started wondering what if you could write him into an opera.  Would he be a tenor role or a baritone role?  Would he be the main character or a minor one?  And what would his music sound like?  Would it be martial or simple?  
       The answer to that question lies in some of Grant's own personality traits.  He was a very quiet man whom one friend described ad being "plain as an old stove".  Another thing about Grant is that he was badly tone deaf.  He once boasted that he recognized only two tunes; "One was Yankee Doodle, and the other wasn't," as he said.  Obviously you can't do much with this guy.

So then what do you do?  You make Grant a speaking role.  It's not uncommon in opera to have a character that speaks instead of sings, Njegus from The Merry Widow is one such character.  The other thing you do is make his leitmotif Yankee Doodle.  It was the only tune that Grant recognized, so there's no point in making an original leitmotif for him.  

I think that about covers it.


Wednesday, August 2, 2017

Fast And Furious DUNKIRK Doesn't Let You Breathe




 Suddenly Downfall feels like a kids' movie.  

That sounds strange, but Downfall at least was a typical movie.  By that I mean that it paced itself in such a way that we could explore the characters and see where they're coming from.  

Well, Dunkirk is not that kind of movie. This is a very different kind of movie, one that is insanely difficult to pull off properly.  This is not a story about characters and how they tick.  The moment the film starts it cranks up the action to eleven until about the final six minutes.  It does not allow you to digest what is happening right in front of you.  
      Christopher Nolan wanted to capture the terror and desperation that was a feature of the evacuation at Dunkirk in 1940.  Does he succeed with this objective?  Yes, I would say he did.  You follow the British soldiers as they face enemy bombardment, choppy seas, and dwindling time while they await rescue from Navy-commandeered civilian boats.  You feel the terror that the men felt during those tense hours, whether it's escaping a sinking ship or dodging enemy bullets.  There is not much in the way of dialogue in this film, no speeches, or passing of photos, or anything of that nature.  It's all the soldiers trying to get out of France and get back home to regroup.  It's as if someone went back in time and installed cameras everywhere in order to capture the event in real time. 
      Unfortunately the biggest drawback to this method of storytelling is the sheer amount of nightmare fuel.  War films are going to have frightening images anyway considering the very nature of war itself.  But there are at least three instances of onscreen drownings, four cases of being killed by dive-bombers at point blank range, not to mention numerous deaths by explosions due to U-Boats and mines.  Obviously this is not a movie for the faint of heart, let alone children.  

Normally I would go on about how much of it was historically accurate, but I do not know very much about Dunkirk.  I will have to back and research it again before I can make any judgments in that regard.  

So how do I rate this film?  As a well-thought-out story depicting the frantic hours of the Rescue at Dunkirk, I'd give it a 10 out 10.  However, the sheer intensity of it means that you're at the edge of your seat virtually the whole time.  So this isn't a film that I would rent for a movie night.  In fact, I think this one is best appreciated seeing it once in the cinema.  Trying to see it over and over again will most likely diminish the potency of the story. 



 

 

Monday, May 8, 2017

Addendum on Documentaries Post

As I've been binging on the Space Race (and right in the middle of finishing a Titanic/Eastland project no less!), I have made a couple of further observations about documentaries.  I did not mention these in my main post on the topic and so I will speak of them here.  

The first thing I talked about was listening to how writers use the language in the documentary.  A good writer will be precise in his language and back up his assertions with facts. 
    Sometimes you will get a piece about something in history or science that isn't very well-known.  This is to be expected as history and science are always on the move.  But beware of titles that say "The Untold Story", "The True/Real Story", "The Forgotten Story", or anything like that.  Titles like these sound dramatic and may get the viewer interested, but they make an assertion that may or may not be true.  
        I have read and reread a book called The Sinking of the EASTLAND: America's Forgotten Tragedy.  This is one of the few cases in which the "forgotten" label is justified.  The capsizing has become largely obscure despite happening right in the middle of the Chicago Harbor.  So when the book says that it's a forgotten tragedy, I can believe it.  
        Last week I saw a documentary called "Apollo 13: The Real Story".  How are the makers sure that it's the "real story"?  Most people in the U.S. know about the incident and so to try to claim that there is a real story is foolish at best. 

Which brings me to my second point.  Take note of the documentary's tone.  Every now and then you will get a documentary written by someone with an axe to grind be it political, social, or whatever.  When that happens you sometimes get conspiracy theories.  And conspiracy theories will be heavy handed and unpleasant.  Last week I tried watching a documentary called Secret Space: The Soyuz 1 Coverup.  I wanted to know about the Soyuz 1 disaster that killed Russian cosmonaut Vladimir Komarov.  The documentary indulged in the Ilyushin myth and even claimed that Yuri Gagarin's death in a plane crash was engineered by Brezhnev.  And the narration throughout the documentary was harsh and unsubtle.  
     It is true that the Soviet government tried to cover up a lot of things.  But the conspiracy theories and overall harsh tone of the documentary made it unwatchable.  

I like documentaries that are objective with their language.  If you want to say that something is the "Untold/Real/Forgotten Story" or whatever, you have to be able to back up your assertion.  While something may be genuinely obscure like in the case of the Eastland, others may seem obscure but turn out to be little more than fringe activities that had been part of an ongoing issue.  Or it may turn out be a conspiracy theory, which means someone is telling a lie.  Use language precisely.  

Monday, February 13, 2017

How To Tell A Good Documentary From A Bad One

We've all seen documentaries at some point or another.  They are all over movies, television, and the internet, and they cover everything from dinosaurs to Operation Desert Storm.  Some are less than half and hour in length while others can go on for two hours.  And often they are part of a long series with a particular theme, like disasters, mummies, scandals, etc..  I have watched numerous documentaries over the course of twenty three years and have recently started to learn how to tell the difference between a good documentary and a bad one.  Now this can be tricky, so the way to vet your sources is to actively research the topic on your own.

How can you tell a good documentary from a bad one?  Well, here are a few things to look for.
     
1) How is the language being used?  Are the people being precise?  Are they repeating themselves?  Are they going out their way to be dramatic?  Being precise is very important because you want the audience to understand what you are saying.  No one is going to understand you if you are being vague and unclear with what you are trying to get across.  And persistent repetition is a sure sign that you are just trying to fill in the spaces and hoping that if you repeat yourself over and over again, people will believe what you are saying.  It is very tempting to be dramatic in order to hold the audience's attention, but many of these topics are dramatic already, so trying to make them even more so is Coals to Newcastle. 

2) How are the makers supporting their claims?  What evidence are they using to back up their arguments?  And are they exploring other possibilities in case they are wrong?  Sometimes the evidence being examined is good, but sometimes it is less than insufficient.     
       For example, a story that sounds juicy might have some good insight into a situation, but then again it could be the exception rather than the rule.  You may decide you want to use it to support your claim, but the use of juicy stories when doing documentaries is dubious at best and dishonest at worst.  And there may be other possible reasons for something, so give some time to those possibilities as well.  Biased sampling tends to skew results.
        
3) How is the documentary presented?  Be mindful of the use of visuals.  There are two ways to do this.  One is to use either Live Actors or CGI, the other is to use pictures, artifacts, and location shots.  Let's look at these two methods.
          Using live actors and/or Computer Generated Imagery isn't a bad thing in and of itself, but it is all too easy for them to upstage everything else.  A good director knows how to use live actors and CGI to illustrate the point and not overpower the audience's retinas. 
        Live actors have been used in documentaries for years.  There are some advantages to this.  Being able to present a historical event with real people acting out the parts can make history look more alive and real.  And it means that someone can get into another person's mind in order to try to understand them.  However, one problem with this method is that the audience just sees one person's interpretation of a historical person, and so that's the one that sticks with them, which could skew someone's perception of history.  Also, people tend to cast actors whose are photogenic, so the audience may not realize that King Tutankhamen was actually club-footed and had an overbite.  

       CGI has its uses as well.  Aside from bringing dinosaurs, mammoths, and other prehistoric creatures back to life, it has been used in live-action documentaries when working with such things historic volcanic eruptions and major battles.  It can digitally restore ruined buildings and illustrate the incredible world of microorganisms.  All in all, CGI has been a great tool for demonstration in documentaries.  That being said, CGI has to be used very carefully.  Spectacular special effects can distract very easily from the main point, resulting in a visual feast that doesn't really serve any purpose.  
  
The second option involves panning the camera over photographs, paintings, statues, etc. if live footage cannot be used*.  Often music and sound effects will be used to help evoke particular scene. This particular style is known as the Ken Burns effect, named after a filmmaker who made much use of this technique is his documentaries.  
    The advantages to using static images is that is much less expensive than hiring actors and spending money on complex animation programs.  You can evoke the scene just by panning over a lithograph of the Battle of Antietam and adding in prerecording sound effects of gunshots and cannon fire.  And it also means that typically you'll be looking at a picture from that era rather than animation where you'd just be making up the scene.  
    The disadvantages of just panning over static images is that it doesn't represent fully what you're trying to accomplish.  A painting of Colonel Chamberlain's Charge at Little Round Top may look lifelike, but it cannot accomplish the same thing that a group of Civil War reenactors can.  And unlike photographs which are taken with cameras at the scene, paintings, lithographs, and engravings are more likely to be stylized, and thus not fully representative of the event.  

 4) What sources are being used?  This is absolutely critical.  People who are active in science, history, etc., will know the ins and outs of the subject matter.  They will ask questions and seek the answers to them, and usually they will find them even if it isn't the answer they may have originally had in mind.  For example, an archeologist trying to understand how the people of Herculaneum lived before the 79 A.D. eruption of Mt. Vesuvius might examine the contents of the sewer in order to ascertain the diet of the average person.  Further information can be obtained be chemical analysis of the bones found in the boathouses.  And the resulting information gives not just the archeologist but the audience watching the documentary a new insight into the lives of a group of people who lived 2,000 years ago.   
      The danger in this case is putting the emphasis on speculation and mystery.  While mystery may be part of the appeal of dinosaurs, most of us actually want to solve the mystery and see how these creatures really lived.  As C.S. Lewis once said, "Inquiry was made for truth,".  And we ask questions because we want to know the answers even if we cannot fully know them because the dinosaurs all died 65 million years before humans came along.  If the people making the documentary go out of their way to be all about speculation without any real answers, then they have not done anything to benefit the audience. 
       And then there are speculative documentaries about things like aliens, ghosts, and that sort of claptrap.  Neither of those things are real and while it's fun to write all sorts of amazing stories about them, it's a waste of time trying to figure out if they even exist.  So don't even bother with that sort of thing.   

I myself do not claim to be an expert on history and science, but I do love learning about both, and I want to know that when I'm watching a documentary that the people who made tried to teach me something.  I once had to sit through a very biased documentary on the American Justice System, and I tried to watch one that spent ten minutes saying how bad the devastation of Carthage was.  I like documentaries that teach me something new as the one on Life and Death in Herculaneum did.  

Of course even the best documentaries cannot compare with books. 


___________________________________________________________________________________
*Thank you Wikipedia.  

Updated 3-6-17 at 6:14 pm.