Tuesday, May 9, 2017
HOLY MOSES!
Here I am wondering if my favorite Russian baritone will come back to the stage, and wouldn't you know it, he does a surprise performance at the Met's 50th Annniversay-At-Lincoln-Center Gala! Either Dima is made of iron, or else he's got Rainbow Dash's determination.
Monday, May 8, 2017
Addendum on Documentaries Post
As I've been binging on the Space Race (and right in the middle of finishing a Titanic/Eastland project no less!), I have made a couple of further observations about documentaries. I did not mention these in my main post on the topic and so I will speak of them here.
The first thing I talked about was listening to how writers use the language in the documentary. A good writer will be precise in his language and back up his assertions with facts.
Sometimes you will get a piece about something in history or science that isn't very well-known. This is to be expected as history and science are always on the move. But beware of titles that say "The Untold Story", "The True/Real Story", "The Forgotten Story", or anything like that. Titles like these sound dramatic and may get the viewer interested, but they make an assertion that may or may not be true.
I have read and reread a book called The Sinking of the EASTLAND: America's Forgotten Tragedy. This is one of the few cases in which the "forgotten" label is justified. The capsizing has become largely obscure despite happening right in the middle of the Chicago Harbor. So when the book says that it's a forgotten tragedy, I can believe it.
Last week I saw a documentary called "Apollo 13: The Real Story". How are the makers sure that it's the "real story"? Most people in the U.S. know about the incident and so to try to claim that there is a real story is foolish at best.
Which brings me to my second point. Take note of the documentary's tone. Every now and then you will get a documentary written by someone with an axe to grind be it political, social, or whatever. When that happens you sometimes get conspiracy theories. And conspiracy theories will be heavy handed and unpleasant. Last week I tried watching a documentary called Secret Space: The Soyuz 1 Coverup. I wanted to know about the Soyuz 1 disaster that killed Russian cosmonaut Vladimir Komarov. The documentary indulged in the Ilyushin myth and even claimed that Yuri Gagarin's death in a plane crash was engineered by Brezhnev. And the narration throughout the documentary was harsh and unsubtle.
It is true that the Soviet government tried to cover up a lot of things. But the conspiracy theories and overall harsh tone of the documentary made it unwatchable.
I like documentaries that are objective with their language. If you want to say that something is the "Untold/Real/Forgotten Story" or whatever, you have to be able to back up your assertion. While something may be genuinely obscure like in the case of the Eastland, others may seem obscure but turn out to be little more than fringe activities that had been part of an ongoing issue. Or it may turn out be a conspiracy theory, which means someone is telling a lie. Use language precisely.
The first thing I talked about was listening to how writers use the language in the documentary. A good writer will be precise in his language and back up his assertions with facts.
Sometimes you will get a piece about something in history or science that isn't very well-known. This is to be expected as history and science are always on the move. But beware of titles that say "The Untold Story", "The True/Real Story", "The Forgotten Story", or anything like that. Titles like these sound dramatic and may get the viewer interested, but they make an assertion that may or may not be true.
I have read and reread a book called The Sinking of the EASTLAND: America's Forgotten Tragedy. This is one of the few cases in which the "forgotten" label is justified. The capsizing has become largely obscure despite happening right in the middle of the Chicago Harbor. So when the book says that it's a forgotten tragedy, I can believe it.
Last week I saw a documentary called "Apollo 13: The Real Story". How are the makers sure that it's the "real story"? Most people in the U.S. know about the incident and so to try to claim that there is a real story is foolish at best.
Which brings me to my second point. Take note of the documentary's tone. Every now and then you will get a documentary written by someone with an axe to grind be it political, social, or whatever. When that happens you sometimes get conspiracy theories. And conspiracy theories will be heavy handed and unpleasant. Last week I tried watching a documentary called Secret Space: The Soyuz 1 Coverup. I wanted to know about the Soyuz 1 disaster that killed Russian cosmonaut Vladimir Komarov. The documentary indulged in the Ilyushin myth and even claimed that Yuri Gagarin's death in a plane crash was engineered by Brezhnev. And the narration throughout the documentary was harsh and unsubtle.
It is true that the Soviet government tried to cover up a lot of things. But the conspiracy theories and overall harsh tone of the documentary made it unwatchable.
I like documentaries that are objective with their language. If you want to say that something is the "Untold/Real/Forgotten Story" or whatever, you have to be able to back up your assertion. While something may be genuinely obscure like in the case of the Eastland, others may seem obscure but turn out to be little more than fringe activities that had been part of an ongoing issue. Or it may turn out be a conspiracy theory, which means someone is telling a lie. Use language precisely.
Tuesday, May 2, 2017
What?
Can someone please explain why a very good documentary on the Soviet Space Program is produced by a company with the name UFOTV?
Saturday, April 22, 2017
ONEGIN
I am listening to Tchaikovsky's Eugene Onegin right now. Peter Mattei is a good singer, and no doubt he's a good Onegin, but it still hurts somewhat to think that Dmitri Hvorostovsky had to cancel his performance in this same role in this same production due to cancer. I wish good luck for Mattei and a swift recovery and a speeedy return to the stage for Dima.
Friday, April 14, 2017
Morgado's Misstep
Two years ago I wrote a rather scathing review of the movie Son of God, and one of negative points I listed was having and attractive actor play Jesus as though having Christ look attractive was bad thing. In retrospect this was unfairly harsh as Christ has been portrayed as beautiful for centuries.
I now recognize that this has more to do with reverence for His deity more than anything else. Even if Isaiah did prophesy that Christ would "have no beauty that we should desire Him", we still want to be reverent in how we depict Him. And portraying Him as looking rather plain just wouldn't fit. Also, Isaiah's prophesy refers more to a flash-and-bang style of charisma than physical appearance.
I guess what bothered me about Diogo Morgado's portrayal of Christ in Son of God was the fact that he looked too handsome. This wasn't the reverent beauty so often found in art, this was the Hollywood-It-Guy variety. And having Jesus look like the hottest male celebrity distracts the audience and takes away from our LORD's deity.
And the performance was too soft. There was no righteous fury evident in the Cleansing of the Temple scene, nor did Morgado seem to show any real emotion other than hippie-style tranquility, the only major exception of course being the crucifixion. Heck, he even smiled after turning the tables over, whatever happened to, "IT IS WRITTEN, 'MY HOUSE IS TO BE A HOUSE OF PRAYER', AND YOU HAVE TURNED INTO A DEN OF THIEVES!"? Yes, Jesus would have roared those words at the top of His lungs. The veins in His forehead would have been popping. He was literally flipping over tables and driving the thieving merchants off the premises! He was releasing animals out of their cages and out of the temple. He. was. furious. And to not see that present was a major misstep.
To make a long story short, irreverent Hollywood good looks and a Nice-Guy portrayal of Jesus Christ derailed the film Son of God.
I now recognize that this has more to do with reverence for His deity more than anything else. Even if Isaiah did prophesy that Christ would "have no beauty that we should desire Him", we still want to be reverent in how we depict Him. And portraying Him as looking rather plain just wouldn't fit. Also, Isaiah's prophesy refers more to a flash-and-bang style of charisma than physical appearance.
I guess what bothered me about Diogo Morgado's portrayal of Christ in Son of God was the fact that he looked too handsome. This wasn't the reverent beauty so often found in art, this was the Hollywood-It-Guy variety. And having Jesus look like the hottest male celebrity distracts the audience and takes away from our LORD's deity.
And the performance was too soft. There was no righteous fury evident in the Cleansing of the Temple scene, nor did Morgado seem to show any real emotion other than hippie-style tranquility, the only major exception of course being the crucifixion. Heck, he even smiled after turning the tables over, whatever happened to, "IT IS WRITTEN, 'MY HOUSE IS TO BE A HOUSE OF PRAYER', AND YOU HAVE TURNED INTO A DEN OF THIEVES!"? Yes, Jesus would have roared those words at the top of His lungs. The veins in His forehead would have been popping. He was literally flipping over tables and driving the thieving merchants off the premises! He was releasing animals out of their cages and out of the temple. He. was. furious. And to not see that present was a major misstep.
To make a long story short, irreverent Hollywood good looks and a Nice-Guy portrayal of Jesus Christ derailed the film Son of God.
Tuesday, March 7, 2017
Weather
Many years ago my maternal grandfather boasted that he was old enough to remember when the weatherman was right. Well, considering the mild inaccuracies I'm seeing in tonight's forecast, I think he may have had a point.
Wednesday, February 22, 2017
Organ Arrangments, Sometime They Work, And Sometimes They Don't.
Yesterday saw another organ concert at the Overture Center in Madison. A little history behind these: At the turn of the 20th Century many cities were competing to build bigger auditoriums with bigger pipe organs. Because people in smaller towns could not get access to big orchestra performances, many people started arranging various orchestral and operatic works for pipe organ. These arrangements would be performed in the auditoriums for people in these small cities.
At yesterday's concert the program was divided into two parts, one Oratorio section and one Opera section. Sun Prairie's own resident opera singer Kyle Ketelsen and tenor Andrew Bidlack performed alongside Madison Symphony Orchestra Principal Organist Samuel Hutchinson. I have no complaints about their performances at all, they were pure gold (although seriously, do you really expect me to have any criticism of Mr. Ketelsen at all?). The program included works from Handel's famous oratorio The Messiah (known mostly by the "Hallelujah" chorus taken from The Book of Revelation) Mendelssohn's Elijah (which I've hardly heard in twenty years), and excerpts from Rossini's Stabat Mater. These pieces fit perfectly with organ.
The opera section was more hit or miss. Not that the men's performances were hit or miss—quite the contrary, they knocked it out of the park!—but unfortunately some of the tunes just didn't have the same oomph that the regular orchestral pieces did. The excerpts featured in this section included the Intermezzo from Mascagni's Cavalleria Rusticana (best known for being double-billed with Leoncavallo's I Pagliacci), themes and the Toreador song from Bizet's Carmen (one the Big Four), the Polonaise and Lensky's Lament from Tchaikovsky's Eugene Onegin (perhaps the most famous Russian opera in the world), and the Waltz and Act 1 duet from Gounod's Faust (one of only two of his works that's still regularly performed in our day).
The trouble is that the organ seems to work better for sacred works and oratorio pieces than it does for opera. Operas may have music for the organ, but transcriptions are another species entirely. The Polonaise and Intermezzo worked well with the organ, but many of the themes from Carmen are just too jaunty and brassy to work well on the organ. It was Mr. Ketelsen's talented singing and acting that made this arrangement of the Toreador Song enjoyable. And the Waltz from Faust also came off as less of a dance piece and more like a carousel ride. But there was no issue with the duet and the organ.
This was a good concert, but I think that there are limits as to which pieces sound good when transcribed for organ and some that don't.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)