I Don't Know, But...has two recent blog posts about what he refers to as "evil songs". These include songs like "Sweet Dreams", "Owner of a Lonely Heart?", etc..
I am not surprised that these songs are described as evil, because quite frankly they are. The thesis of "Sweet Dreams" is that love is a lie and people are only looking to use and abuse people. The music is ghastly as are the lyrics. It sounds like someone has been so badly hurt by a luckless relationship that they have given up on ever knowing love.
"Owner of a Lonely Heart" is even more disturbing with the line "Better than the owner of a broken heart". If I may steal from the recent opera The Enchanted Island, hearts that love all will be broken. You cannot love without risking pain. C.S. Lewis once noted that the only place where you are safe from the pains of love is Hell. I myself have heard it said that it is better to have loved and lost than to have never loved at all.
I have sung many songs about unrequited/spurned love, but they were more about how the narrator couldn't go on living without the beloved or dying on a kiss. They never crossed the line by saying that love was a lie or that it was better to never love at all. People need to know that they are loved, and it starts with one person making the decision to love someone. This is not limited to just romantic love, but to friendship and familial love as well.
Granted one person hearing "Sweet Dreams" might say, "Right on," while another says, "I love a sad song." But it's still very sickening to hear such nasty and wicked lyrics oveer the radio.
Monday, November 18, 2019
Wednesday, October 16, 2019
New Statue
He would have been fifty-seven today, had cancer not taken him in 2017. It still hurt to think about it.
A statue of Dmitri Hvorostovsky was unveiled in Novodevichy Cemetery today. It's amazing how much of an icon he is over in Russia. But here in the U.S., he's hardly known at all unless you're a Russian immigrant or an opera geek.
I really have no words to describe just how much Dima meant to me, but it was through his performance over the radio of Eugene Onegin that I fell in love with opera to being with. With that dark velvety voice, that piercing dark eyes, and that white mane, what women wouldn't be swept off her feet by him?
What makes his loss all the more painful is that he was fifty-five when he passed. Now that shouldn't be too unusual, but we all had the hope that Dima would sing until he was eighty. So it does feel like he went too soon.
A statue of Dmitri Hvorostovsky was unveiled in Novodevichy Cemetery today. It's amazing how much of an icon he is over in Russia. But here in the U.S., he's hardly known at all unless you're a Russian immigrant or an opera geek.
I really have no words to describe just how much Dima meant to me, but it was through his performance over the radio of Eugene Onegin that I fell in love with opera to being with. With that dark velvety voice, that piercing dark eyes, and that white mane, what women wouldn't be swept off her feet by him?
What makes his loss all the more painful is that he was fifty-five when he passed. Now that shouldn't be too unusual, but we all had the hope that Dima would sing until he was eighty. So it does feel like he went too soon.
Sunday, October 13, 2019
Art Is Calling For Me
I really wish I could find a full synopsis of The Enchantress, because I want the context for this song. It was written in 1911 but the lyrics are such that I would swear it was written by the musical comedienne Anna Russel.
The song is your typical "I Want More" piece sung by a young lady (Stellina) who has everything but is not satisfied. She wants to be the next Adelina Patti and sing on the stage. Lines such as "I hate society,/ I hate propriety!" highlight the lady's rebelliousness. As I do not know the story, I would say it is open to interpretation whether or not this is a woman with genuine talent who could conceivably make it on the stage, or else a wannabe who's just bored with high society.
As it was written in 1911, most of the references are to singers who were around at the time (Luisa Tetrazzini, Nellie Melba), and who are unfortunately not as well-known in our culture today unless you're an opera geek.
The song is your typical "I Want More" piece sung by a young lady (Stellina) who has everything but is not satisfied. She wants to be the next Adelina Patti and sing on the stage. Lines such as "I hate society,/ I hate propriety!" highlight the lady's rebelliousness. As I do not know the story, I would say it is open to interpretation whether or not this is a woman with genuine talent who could conceivably make it on the stage, or else a wannabe who's just bored with high society.
As it was written in 1911, most of the references are to singers who were around at the time (Luisa Tetrazzini, Nellie Melba), and who are unfortunately not as well-known in our culture today unless you're an opera geek.
The music is surprisingly easy—relatively speaking, of course—but it is also very high, going up to a high B-flat. But then this piece also allows for a lot of ornamentation. Given what this song is about, it works perfectly. In my own practice, I have ended the song on an E-flat about High C. I have heard other recordings of sopranos going into cadenzas.
Art Is Calling For Me is fast becoming a favorite of mine, if for no other reason than it is fun. This is a song that I would recommend to other sopranos, and maybe even the daring mezzo.
Sunday, October 6, 2019
Double Whammy 2
Two great opera singers died this past week, soprano Jessye Norman at 74, and tenor Marcello Giordani at 56. I had only seen Ms. Norman in a few clips of Die Walkure, but I remember seeing Signor Giordani in the encore simulcast of Verdi's Ernani in 2012. But they were both really awesome singers who were adored by opera lovers everywhere.
They will be greatly missed.
Friday, September 27, 2019
Church Music
My church has two different kinds of services on Sunday. One does contemporary styles, the other is more traditional; while it does not have a choir, does do the older hymns that (mostly) everyone knows and loves. I prefer the more traditional service, and I have been singing for it for the past few months.
The reasons why I prefer the traditional style are as follows:
1) Being a soprano, I am most comfortable when I can use my range. Granted most hymns don't go higher than "E" Natural, but the hymns allow for more freedom of range than the more contemporary styles of music. The latter usually features sudden octave jumps that tax my upper register. When it's not that, it's taxing on my lower register.
2) I can hear the congregation singing in the traditional service. I don't get that in the contemporary one. The music for contemporary service is too overpowering for me, I can hardly hear myself during worship! But there is only one piano in the traditional one, plus whatever other instruments people on worship team bring (we've got our own brass quartet!).
3) The contemporary style makes worship feel less like worship and more like some popular concert, especially with the loud drums and emphasis on emotion. Making things worse is when worships leaders decide to to jazz up old hymns. Now that in itself is not bad, but the congregation has to be able to sing along. I remember getting so frustrated when the worship team did funky things to the notes and rhythm of a particular hymn that I shouted at them to leave the coloratura to Joyce DiDonato.
With the traditional style, there is less noise to distract me. Maybe the occasional guy clapping on the off-beat, but that's only during the refrain of "Standing on the Promises" and that's only one guy.
In short, I find the traditional style of church music easier to sing. I know others will have differing opinions on this, and that's fine. I just find that contemporary music in worship gives me a major case of sensory overload, and that is not something I want in worship.
The reasons why I prefer the traditional style are as follows:
1) Being a soprano, I am most comfortable when I can use my range. Granted most hymns don't go higher than "E" Natural, but the hymns allow for more freedom of range than the more contemporary styles of music. The latter usually features sudden octave jumps that tax my upper register. When it's not that, it's taxing on my lower register.
2) I can hear the congregation singing in the traditional service. I don't get that in the contemporary one. The music for contemporary service is too overpowering for me, I can hardly hear myself during worship! But there is only one piano in the traditional one, plus whatever other instruments people on worship team bring (we've got our own brass quartet!).
3) The contemporary style makes worship feel less like worship and more like some popular concert, especially with the loud drums and emphasis on emotion. Making things worse is when worships leaders decide to to jazz up old hymns. Now that in itself is not bad, but the congregation has to be able to sing along. I remember getting so frustrated when the worship team did funky things to the notes and rhythm of a particular hymn that I shouted at them to leave the coloratura to Joyce DiDonato.
With the traditional style, there is less noise to distract me. Maybe the occasional guy clapping on the off-beat, but that's only during the refrain of "Standing on the Promises" and that's only one guy.
In short, I find the traditional style of church music easier to sing. I know others will have differing opinions on this, and that's fine. I just find that contemporary music in worship gives me a major case of sensory overload, and that is not something I want in worship.
Sunday, September 15, 2019
Shockers
I have taken my boyfriend to see three operas at Madison Opera and two of them really shocked him. These were Carmen (natch) and Rusalka.
Carmen is shocking by the very nature of the story. Carmen forces herself onto Jose never mind what consequences might follow. She is obsessed with power and revels in using other people to get it. In our day she's seen as some kind of champion for freedom, although I find that to be rather dubious. What kind of person goes out of her way to use people in order to maintain her "freedom"?
Although I had warned my boyfriend of this one, it still left him reeling; it took him two days to finally talk about it. I guess he could not believe that such a nasty person could exist. And Carmen is an enigma, both in and out of the story. The premiere caused a scandal, which only served to make it more famous. The music is iconic, and is Bizet's absolute best.
Rusalka is a tragic fairy tale where the water nymph tries and fails to win the love of a mortal prince and becomes a deadly siren. While not as famous as Carmen, it does have Song to the Moon, one of Dvořák's greatest musical masterpieces.
The ending made my boyfriend want to rewrite the ending of The Little Mermaid (which the opera is based off of). I for one did not find it a shocker, but the third act made me cry. It is painful watching a someone try so hard to achieve the goal only for it the evade them. And nothing is more painful than becoming a spirit of death.
Carmen is shocking by the very nature of the story. Carmen forces herself onto Jose never mind what consequences might follow. She is obsessed with power and revels in using other people to get it. In our day she's seen as some kind of champion for freedom, although I find that to be rather dubious. What kind of person goes out of her way to use people in order to maintain her "freedom"?
Although I had warned my boyfriend of this one, it still left him reeling; it took him two days to finally talk about it. I guess he could not believe that such a nasty person could exist. And Carmen is an enigma, both in and out of the story. The premiere caused a scandal, which only served to make it more famous. The music is iconic, and is Bizet's absolute best.
Rusalka is a tragic fairy tale where the water nymph tries and fails to win the love of a mortal prince and becomes a deadly siren. While not as famous as Carmen, it does have Song to the Moon, one of Dvořák's greatest musical masterpieces.
The ending made my boyfriend want to rewrite the ending of The Little Mermaid (which the opera is based off of). I for one did not find it a shocker, but the third act made me cry. It is painful watching a someone try so hard to achieve the goal only for it the evade them. And nothing is more painful than becoming a spirit of death.
Sunday, September 8, 2019
Liberty Corrupted
Simon Keenlyside argued that Don Giovanni is thinking about liberty. Maybe. However, Giovanni's idea of liberty seems to be ruining the marriage prospects of as many women as he can. Freedom isn't freedom if you're going out of your way to hurt people.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


